WEBVTT

00:00:06.651 --> 00:00:07.418
CHARLES: SHORT TIME AGO DIRECTOR

00:00:07.419 --> 00:00:08.152
OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE ISSUING

00:00:08.153 --> 00:00:09.987
A STERN WARNING TO MEDIA OUTLETS

00:00:09.988 --> 00:00:11.989
BE AWARE OF EFFORTS BY FOREIGN

00:00:11.990 --> 00:00:13.424
GOVERNMENTS TO PLACE PROPAGANDA

00:00:13.425 --> 00:00:14.825
NEWS STORIES HERE AT HOME.

00:00:14.826 --> 00:00:16.494
TAKE A LISTEN.

00:00:16.495 --> 00:00:17.962
>> RESPONSIBILITY DOESN'T STOP

00:00:17.963 --> 00:00:20.030
WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.

00:00:20.031 --> 00:00:22.633
WE ALSO NEED THE PRIVATE SECTOR

00:00:22.634 --> 00:00:25.035
AND MEDIA OUTLETS TO STEP UP AND

00:00:25.036 --> 00:00:28.472
TAKE GREATER RESPONSIBILITY

00:00:28.473 --> 00:00:32.143
BECAUSE THIS THIS, A NATIONAL

00:00:32.144 --> 00:00:33.878
INTEREST, THIS IS A NATIONAL

00:00:33.879 --> 00:00:36.414
INTEREST THAT DEMANDS A RESPONSE

00:00:36.415 --> 00:00:38.849
FROM THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AND

00:00:38.850 --> 00:00:40.151
THE PRIVATE SECTOR.

00:00:40.152 --> 00:00:45.523
CHARLES: LISA GASH -- GARBER IS

00:00:45.524 --> 00:00:47.091
A PRIVATE SECURITY EXPERT AND

00:00:47.092 --> 00:00:48.125
JOINS US RIGHT NOW.

00:00:48.126 --> 00:00:49.794
DAN COATS, WHEN HE TALKS ABOUT

00:00:49.795 --> 00:00:52.062
MEDIA OUTLETS, INCLUDES NEW

00:00:52.063 --> 00:00:52.363
MEDIA.

00:00:52.364 --> 00:00:54.465
HAS TO, GOT TO INCLUDE TWITTER,

00:00:54.466 --> 00:00:57.034
GOT TO INCLUDE FACEBOOK AND

00:00:57.035 --> 00:00:58.369
THOSE ENTITIES AS WELL.

00:00:58.370 --> 00:00:59.770
THERE IS MORAL OBLIGATION

00:00:59.771 --> 00:01:00.604
SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS.

00:01:00.605 --> 00:01:03.874
AT SOME POINT THERE WILL A LEGAL

00:01:03.875 --> 00:01:04.275
OBLIGATION.

00:01:04.276 --> 00:01:06.010
HOW DO YOU SEE IT PLAYING OUT?

00:01:06.011 --> 00:01:08.412
>> DAN COATS SUMMED UP THE

00:01:08.413 --> 00:01:10.448
RESPONSIBILITY THAT THE

00:01:10.449 --> 00:01:11.982
GOVERNMENT SEES FOR GLOBAL MEDIA

00:01:11.983 --> 00:01:13.684
PLATFORMS THAT ALLOW FOR

00:01:13.685 --> 00:01:14.118
COMMUNICATION.

00:01:14.119 --> 00:01:15.419
THE PART OF THE ISSUE, PRIVATE

00:01:15.420 --> 00:01:16.654
COMPANIES LIKE TWITTER,

00:01:16.655 --> 00:01:18.823
FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, ALLOW

00:01:18.824 --> 00:01:19.557
COMMUNICATIONS FROM COMMUNITIES

00:01:19.558 --> 00:01:22.493
THAT ARE TRYING TO MAINTAIN

00:01:22.494 --> 00:01:23.794
PRIVACY LIKE TERRORISTS AND

00:01:23.795 --> 00:01:25.930
PEOPLE HARBORING MENACING

00:01:25.931 --> 00:01:27.198
THOUGHTS AND TRYING TO CEMENT

00:01:27.199 --> 00:01:28.499
ALL THESE PROBLEMS FOR THE

00:01:28.500 --> 00:01:29.900
AMERICAN COMMUNITY AND AMERICAN

00:01:29.901 --> 00:01:30.234
PUBLIC.

00:01:30.235 --> 00:01:30.835
THE GOVERNMENT DOESN'T

00:01:30.836 --> 00:01:32.203
NECESSARILY HAVE ACCESS TO THAT.

00:01:32.204 --> 00:01:33.170
CHARLES: THE GOVERNMENT DOESN'T

00:01:33.171 --> 00:01:34.472
HAVE ACCESS TO IT.

00:01:34.473 --> 00:01:36.574
MEANTIME, YOU KNOW, LAST WEEK

00:01:36.575 --> 00:01:38.309
ANOTHER WAVE OF PEOPLE ON

00:01:38.310 --> 00:01:39.977
TWITTER, CONSERVATIVES LOSING

00:01:39.978 --> 00:01:43.113
THEIR FOLLOWERS AND THEY WEREN'T

00:01:43.114 --> 00:01:43.414
BOTS.

00:01:43.415 --> 00:01:45.282
THEY WERE AUNT MAY, IT WAS HER

00:01:45.283 --> 00:01:46.383
TWITTER HANDLE.

00:01:46.384 --> 00:01:49.620
ONLY HAD PEOPLE WAKING UP WITH

00:01:49.621 --> 00:01:51.822
100 FOLLOWERS, HAD 200 THE NIGHT

00:01:51.823 --> 00:01:52.223
BEFORE.

00:01:52.224 --> 00:01:53.257
FOR SOME REASON THEY SEEM TO BE

00:01:53.258 --> 00:01:55.493
ON TOP OF THIS STUFF, FACEBOOK,

00:01:55.494 --> 00:01:58.062
TWITTER, THEY SEEM TO BE ABLE TO

00:01:58.063 --> 00:02:00.130
POLICE POLITICAL SPEAK THEY

00:02:00.131 --> 00:02:02.166
THINK IS INAPPROPRIATE BUT

00:02:02.167 --> 00:02:03.868
UNABLE EFFECTIVELY POLICE

00:02:03.869 --> 00:02:05.469
EFFORTS OF THOSE WHO ARE TRYING

00:02:05.470 --> 00:02:06.070
TO ROIL OUR COUNTRY.

00:02:06.071 --> 00:02:08.172
>> IT IS SO FRUSTRATING.

00:02:08.173 --> 00:02:10.007
EVEN MARK ZUCKERBERG WHO IS

00:02:10.008 --> 00:02:11.141
CONTINUALLY ASKED WHERE ARE YOU

00:02:11.142 --> 00:02:12.576
GOING TO DRAW THE LINE FOR

00:02:12.577 --> 00:02:13.844
POLITICAL CONTROVERSIES, TRYING

00:02:13.845 --> 00:02:15.379
TO FIGURE OUT FOLLOWER ISSUES

00:02:15.380 --> 00:02:16.714
AND WHERE WILL YOU FIGURE OUT

00:02:16.715 --> 00:02:17.815
THE FAKE NEWS?

00:02:17.816 --> 00:02:19.116
WHERE WILL YOU FIGURE OUT, WHERE

00:02:19.117 --> 00:02:22.820
WILL YOU DRAW THE LINE FOR THESE

00:02:22.821 --> 00:02:25.189
CONTROVERSY HE CONTINUALLY SAYS

00:02:25.190 --> 00:02:27.224
I'M CEO BUT SHOULDN'T BE MY

00:02:27.225 --> 00:02:27.691
RESPONSIBILITY.

00:02:27.692 --> 00:02:28.792
WHOSE RESPONSIBILITY IS IT?

00:02:28.793 --> 00:02:31.195
THE GOVERNMENT WILL STEP IN AND

00:02:31.196 --> 00:02:32.630
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF HIGHLY

00:02:32.631 --> 00:02:34.064
OPERATIONAL TECHNOLOGIES AND

00:02:34.065 --> 00:02:35.165
TACTICS THESE PRIVATE COMPANIES

00:02:35.166 --> 00:02:39.036
ALREADY HAVE ACCESS TO, AND SAY,

00:02:39.037 --> 00:02:40.938
OKAY, ZUCKERBERG SHOULD NOT BE

00:02:40.939 --> 00:02:42.306
THE MAN IN CHARGE OF DETERMINING

00:02:42.307 --> 00:02:44.408
WHOSE FOLLOWERS GET TAKEN DOWN

00:02:44.409 --> 00:02:47.545
AND WHAT TERRORISTS GROUPS ARE

00:02:47.546 --> 00:02:49.413
ALLOWED TO FOMENT PROBLEMS ON

00:02:49.414 --> 00:02:49.780
PLATFORM.

00:02:49.781 --> 00:02:50.814
CHARLES: INTERESTING THEY BACK

00:02:50.815 --> 00:02:52.149
AWAY FROM THE RESPONSIBILITY BUT

00:02:52.150 --> 00:02:53.217
AT THE SAME TIME THEY HAVE

00:02:53.218 --> 00:02:54.518
INSATIABLE APPETITE TO KNOW

00:02:54.519 --> 00:02:56.086
EVERYTHING ABOUT US AND COLLECT

00:02:56.087 --> 00:02:56.387
DATA.

00:02:56.388 --> 00:02:58.789
A GREAT STORY CAME OUT.

00:02:58.790 --> 00:02:59.957
APPARENTLY WITH FACEBOOK, IN

00:02:59.958 --> 00:03:01.759
THEIR NEWPORT TALL, IN-HOME

00:03:01.760 --> 00:03:02.793
VIDEO SYSTEM.

00:03:02.794 --> 00:03:05.763
INITIALLY THEY TOLL FOLKS AT

00:03:05.764 --> 00:03:07.631
THERE WAS NO DATA COLLECTION

00:03:07.632 --> 00:03:11.435
THROUGH THIS PORTAL.

00:03:11.436 --> 00:03:13.604
THEN THEY KIND OF CHANGED THEIR

00:03:13.605 --> 00:03:13.904
MINE.

00:03:13.905 --> 00:03:15.573
THERE IS NO NECESSARILY DATA

00:03:15.574 --> 00:03:17.107
COLLECTION BUT THE PORTAL CAN

00:03:17.108 --> 00:03:19.410
TARGET YOU WITH ADS AND OTHER

00:03:19.411 --> 00:03:20.611
FACEBOOK OWNED PROPERTIES MUCH

00:03:20.612 --> 00:03:22.112
IN OTHER WORDS WE DO GET

00:03:22.113 --> 00:03:23.113
INFORMATION, HOW COME THEY CAN'T

00:03:23.114 --> 00:03:24.281
BE STRAIGHT WITH US?

00:03:24.282 --> 00:03:27.051
IT MAKES YOU WONDER ARE THESE

00:03:27.052 --> 00:03:28.385
THINGS UBIQUITOUS, THE SYSTEM

00:03:28.386 --> 00:03:30.788
WILL BE ON OUR HOME, AND AN

00:03:30.789 --> 00:03:32.690
ALEXA ON TOP OF THE

00:03:32.691 --> 00:03:33.624
REFRIGERATOR, THE IDEA THEY'RE

00:03:33.625 --> 00:03:34.458
TAKING ALL THIS INFORMATION

00:03:34.459 --> 00:03:35.626
AGAINST OUR WILL, PERHAPS

00:03:35.627 --> 00:03:38.596
SELLING IT, CERTAINLY USING IT

00:03:38.597 --> 00:03:39.830
TO SELL US THINGS, SOMEWHERE WE

00:03:39.831 --> 00:03:41.298
HAVE TO DRAW THE LINE.

00:03:41.299 --> 00:03:42.166
>> THAT'S TRUE.

00:03:42.167 --> 00:03:44.568
THIS FALLS UNDER THE UMBRELLA OF

00:03:44.569 --> 00:03:46.837
INTERNET OF THINGS, ANY

00:03:46.838 --> 00:03:48.572
DIGITIZED DEVICE CONNECTS TO THE

00:03:48.573 --> 00:03:50.407
INTERNET, GOOGLE'S HOME, AMAZON

00:03:50.408 --> 00:03:52.142
ECHO AND THE FACEBOOK PORTAL.

00:03:52.143 --> 00:03:54.244
PART OF THE PROBLEM NOT ONLY

00:03:54.245 --> 00:03:55.279
FACEBOOK CHANGING ITS PUBLIC

00:03:55.280 --> 00:03:56.914
STATEMENT OVER THE LAST TWO DAYS

00:03:56.915 --> 00:03:58.682
OVER WHAT KIND OF DATA THEY

00:03:58.683 --> 00:04:00.384
COLLECT, YES, YOU WON'T SEE ADS

00:04:00.385 --> 00:04:03.621
ON THE PORTAL DEVICE WHICH IS A

00:04:03.622 --> 00:04:06.491
VIDEOCONFERENCE DEVICE, BUT